BfoListRealizableEntityDiscussJuly2007


BFO:Realizable Entity: Distinction between Disposition, Function, and Role

This discussion thread took place on the BFO mailing list in July 2007. It is summarized here, since it might provide us with a clearer sense of how to proceed with OBI:Function, which must build off one or more of these BFO realizable entity types. The discussion was heavily edited to hopefully promote clarity - and referencing URLs have been added to help point others to critical background material.
The thread needed to be broken into sub-threads, because it extended beyond the 32kb MediaWiki recommended page limit.

<< Back to OBI Function BFO + Use Case page
<< Back to OBI Function maing page
<< Back to Homepage

Contents


Discussion Participants

  • Bill Bug (BB)
  • Cristian Coscos (CC)
  • Jennifer Fostel (JF)
  • Pierre Grenon (PG)
  • Robert Hoehndorf (RH)
  • Waclaw Kusnierczyk (WK)
  • Kristl Laux (KL)
  • Matthias Samwald (MS)
  • Barry Smith (BS)
  • Alan Ruttenberg (AR)

Discussion Threads

Proposed alternative class axioms for bfo:realizable_entity children to better distinguish amongst them

Improve defintions and examples to better distinguish bfo:disposition, bfo:function, and bfo:role

Human/Social dependence distinshes bfo:role from bfo:disposition/bfo:function

BFO Citations providing distinguishing definitions/axioms for the children of bfo:realizable_entity